THE competition was hot, the verdict is in.

Don’t let the name fool you: the serious topics are addressed on the Blues Banter podcast, presented by Barkly Smokehouse.

With Eddie Betts and Jack Martin on the show, it presented the perfect opportunity for the two to vote on their top five Indigenous players in VFL/AFL history.

07:15 Mins
Published on

Blues Banter | Top five indigenous players

Eddie and Jack list their top five Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander players they've seen.

Published on

The top two were similar, the following three showed the difference of opinion.

With both watching different eras of football, the decision was unanimous at the top of the order: Betts went for the Lance Franklin and Adam Goodes quinella, while Martin’s top two were inverted.

“[Buddy] has done it all… he’s going to go down in the top five players to ever play the game,” Betts said.

“It was hard to split between No.1 and No.2 but I went with Adam Goodes. Dual Brownlow Medallist, dual premiership player… he did it all.”

From there, Betts rounded his top five out with Michael Long, Gavin Wanganeen and Andrew McLeod.

Meanwhile, Martin was more than happy to give his new teammate a spot.

“My No.3 is Eddie Betts. I didn’t watch McLeod, I didn’t watch Michael Long,” he said.

“I can only go on the footy I’ve watched. 300-plus games, 600-plus goals, multiple All Australians, Goal of the Years.”

Betts' top five

Lance Franklin, Adam Goodes, Michael Long, Gavin Wanganeen, Andrew McLeod

Martin's top five

Adam Goodes, Lance Franklin, Eddie Betts, Cyril Rioli, Shaun Burgoyne