CARLTON forwards Matthew Cottrell and Harry McKay have both required surgery after receiving specialist advice in recent days.

The Club had been exploring the best course of rehabilitation for Cottrell over the past fortnight and after further consultation, it was determined that surgery is needed this week to correct a navicular stress fracture, unfortunately sidelining the 25-year-old for the remainder of the 2025 season. 

We really feel for Matthew, he’s the definition of a team-first player who’s enjoyment in footy comes from playing his role for the team, which is what we all love about him,” Carlton General Manager of Football Brad Lloyd said.

“He’s an extremely resilient character, who will no doubt attack his rehab and continue to bring his infectious energy around the group over the coming months.”

McKay had been unable to increase his training loads over the last two weeks, leading to further consultation with a specialist late on Monday afternoon.

That consultation resulted in McKay undergoing a knee arthroscope today, with the key forward expected to return to play between Rounds 19 – 21.

“While a minor procedure isn’t ideal for Harry, it gives him the best opportunity to return to play in the back end of the season,” Lloyd said.

In other news, defender Nic Newman has been given the all-clear this week to begin integrating back into full training with the main group. This will be his focus over the next month, before it is determined whether he will be able to return to play late in the season. 

After being subbed out of Sunday’s win against West Coast as a precaution, Charlie Curnow has been progressing well and will aim to train fully later this week to be available to play against North Melbourne. 
 
Harry McKay (knee)
- Recovery phase
- Availability: Rounds 19 – 21
- Arthroscope completed on his knee, and will commence his rehab following initial recovery from the procedure
 
Matthew Cottrell (foot)
- Recovery phase
- Will miss the remainder of the 2025 season
- Has undergone surgery to correct a navicular stress fracture, ruling him out for the remainder of the 2025 season
  
Hudson O’Keeffe (hamstring)
- Modified program
- Availability: Rounds 18-19
- Scans have confirmed O’Keeffe experienced a low-grade hamstring strain in the third quarter of Sunday night’s win over West Coast.

Charlie Curnow (calf tightness)
- Full training
- Availability: Test
- Will aim to train fully this week to be available to play

Nic Newman (knee)
- Integrate into full training
- Availability: TBC
- Has progressed very well throughout his rehabilitation to now put himself in a position to begin training with the main group. That will be his focus over the next month before it is determined whether he will be able to return to play later in the season
 
Lachie Cowan (hamstring)
- Full training
- Availability: Test 
- Will aim to train this week to be available for selection 
 
Sam Walsh (foot)
- Modified program
- Availability: Rounds 19-20

Injury List

Player Injury Estimated Return
23: Jacob Weitering

23: Jacob Weitering

Calf Test (Update: 4 August)

Integrate into full training. Availability: Test. Will aim to train fully later this week to be available for selection. (Update: 4 August)

25. Liam Reidy

25. Liam Reidy

Concussion Test (Update: 4 August)

Integrate into full training. Availability: Test. Will aim to train fully later this week to be available for selection. (Update: 4 August)

43. Ashton Moir

43. Ashton Moir

Calf Test (Update: 4 August)

Integrate into full training. Availability: Test. Will aim to train fully later this week to be available for selection. (Update: 4 August)

31. Campbell Chesser

31. Campbell Chesser

Knee TBC (Update: 28 July)

Modified program. Availability: TBC. Sustained knee injury against Box Hill: the Club will now work through his recovery timeline over next fortnight. (Update: 28 July)

24. Nic Newman

24. Nic Newman

Hamstring 6-7 weeks (Update: 4 August)

Modified program. Availability: 6-7 weeks. Commenced rehabilitation, with Club to provide further update on progress when he returns to training. (Update: 4 August)

22. Harry O'Farrell

22. Harry O'Farrell

Knee Season (Update: 14 July)

Modified program. Availability: season. Has progressed well through rehab, has now re-joined skills training with the playing group. Will focus on completing the final stages of recovery for remainder of year, putting him in a strong position heading into pre-season.

3. Jesse Motlop

3. Jesse Motlop

Knee Season (Update: 11 January)

Ruptured his anterior cruciate ligament in January. Availability: Season. (Update: 11 January)

32. Matthew Carroll

32. Matthew Carroll

Knee Season (Update: 26 May)

Availability: Season. Scans confirmed ruptured ACL in Round 11. Will have surgery before road to recovery. (Update: 26 May)

34. Rob Monahan

34. Rob Monahan

Shoulder Season (Update: 5 May)

Suffered a dislocated shoulder in the VFL, with the Club determining surgery is required. Rob will undergo surgery before commencing his rehabilitation towards a full recovery. Availability: Season (Update: 5 May)

23: Jacob Weitering

23: Jacob Weitering

Integrate into full training. Availability: Test. Will aim to train fully later this week to be available for selection. (Update: 4 August)

Injury: Calf
Est. Return: Test (Update: 4 August)
25. Liam Reidy

25. Liam Reidy

Integrate into full training. Availability: Test. Will aim to train fully later this week to be available for selection. (Update: 4 August)

Injury: Concussion
Est. Return: Test (Update: 4 August)
43. Ashton Moir

43. Ashton Moir

Integrate into full training. Availability: Test. Will aim to train fully later this week to be available for selection. (Update: 4 August)

Injury: Calf
Est. Return: Test (Update: 4 August)
31. Campbell Chesser

31. Campbell Chesser

Modified program. Availability: TBC. Sustained knee injury against Box Hill: the Club will now work through his recovery timeline over next fortnight. (Update: 28 July)

Injury: Knee
Est. Return: TBC (Update: 28 July)
24. Nic Newman

24. Nic Newman

Modified program. Availability: 6-7 weeks. Commenced rehabilitation, with Club to provide further update on progress when he returns to training. (Update: 4 August)

Injury: Hamstring
Est. Return: 6-7 weeks (Update: 4 August)
22. Harry O'Farrell

22. Harry O'Farrell

Modified program. Availability: season. Has progressed well through rehab, has now re-joined skills training with the playing group. Will focus on completing the final stages of recovery for remainder of year, putting him in a strong position heading into pre-season.

Injury: Knee
Est. Return: Season (Update: 14 July)
3. Jesse Motlop

3. Jesse Motlop

Ruptured his anterior cruciate ligament in January. Availability: Season. (Update: 11 January)

Injury: Knee
Est. Return: Season (Update: 11 January)
32. Matthew Carroll

32. Matthew Carroll

Availability: Season. Scans confirmed ruptured ACL in Round 11. Will have surgery before road to recovery. (Update: 26 May)

Injury: Knee
Est. Return: Season (Update: 26 May)
34. Rob Monahan

34. Rob Monahan

Suffered a dislocated shoulder in the VFL, with the Club determining surgery is required. Rob will undergo surgery before commencing his rehabilitation towards a full recovery. Availability: Season (Update: 5 May)

Injury: Shoulder
Est. Return: Season (Update: 5 May)

Last Updated: